A cognitive constraint in psychophysics about depth perception – the light is always coming from above

 

Ai-Hou Wang, M.D., Ph.D.

 

 

The left and the right are the same picture, upside-down to each other.

The depth perception is reversed.

Our perception always assumes the illuminating light is coming from above.

And this depth perception is quite stable.

 

When the image is placed horizontally, it can be viewed as light shining from the left or from the right. The depth sensation is in a ‘bistable state’ - you cannot see both at the same time.

 

‘Freeze fracture’ in cell biology means to separate the phospholipid bilayer of cell membrane into inner and outer layer by freezing and splitting (see figure). You will then be able to observe with electron microscope the interface between inner and outer layer, to determine whether the transmembrane protein molecules are attached to the inner layer or outer layer.

 

To determine which surface of the split cell membrane are the protein molecules attached to (see figure), we’ve got a problem:

The left and right are the same electron microscopic picture, upside-down to each other.

Due to the constraint of depth perception as described above that ‘the illumination always comes from above’, The concave hole in the left picture changes to convex hemisphere in the right picture.

From the left picture, the protein seems attached to the other side of the split cell membrane; from the right picture, the protein appears attached to this half of the split cell membrane!

This is indeed a problem that must be solved in specimens preparation for electron microscopy.